Optimizing the Proportions of Essential Oils as Aedes aegypti Repellent using Response Surface Methodology
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.55627/pbulletin.004.02.1586Keywords:
Aedes aegypti, Essential oils, Plant-based repellent, Response Surface Methodology, Sustainable vector controlAbstract
Mosquito-borne diseases, particularly those transmitted by Aedes aegypti, pose significant global health risks. Chemical repellents such as DEET are widely used; however, concerns regarding toxicity and environmental safety have increased interest in natural alternatives. Essential oils, with diverse bioactive properties, represent a promising option, though their repellent efficacy depends on the type and proportion of active compounds. This study employed Response Surface Methodology (RSM) to optimize the proportions of neem, lemongrass, sesame, and mint oils for developing an effective plant-based repellent. A total of 27 formulations were prepared and tested against A. aegypti. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) confirmed the statistical significance of the model, demonstrating that repellent activity was strongly influenced by essential oil composition. The optimized formulation consisted of 37.931 parts neem oil, 69.338 parts lemongrass oil, and 2.828 parts sesame oil, with no mint oil. This combination achieved a predicted effectiveness score of 51.548 and a desirability index of 1.00, indicating high performance and stability. Results highlighted neem and lemongrass oils as the primary contributors to repellency, while sesame oil enhanced formulation stability. Overall, the study successfully optimized an essential oil-based repellent, offering a safe, natural, and sustainable alternative to synthetic chemicals with potential for further development and commercialization.
References
Akbar R, Afzal S, Sun J, Faheem B, Bibi R, Azad R, Farid A, Ahmad HI, Ataya FS, Khan MA, Khan IA. Efficacy of Various Plant Extracts and Synergism Against Domestic Species of Rice Weevil Sitophilous oryzae (Curculionidae: Coleoptera). Polish Journal of Environmental Studies. 2024 May 1;33(3).
Akbar R, Faheem B, Aziz T, Ali A, Ullah A, Khan IA, Sun J. Evaluating the efficacy of plant extracts in managing the bruchid beetle, Callosobruchus maculatus (Coleoptera: Bruchidae). Insects. 2024 Sep 12;15(9):691.
Akbar R, Khan IA. Toxicity of five plant extracts against Callosobruchus maculatus Fab.(Coleoptera Bruchidae) a major insect pest of stored pulses. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin. 2021 Jan 1;30(5):5098-107.
Akbar R, Manzoor S, Azad R, Makai G, Rahim J, Sheikh UA, Ali A, Aziz T, Ahmad HI, Ahmed M, Du D. Botanical pesticides: role of Ricinus communis in managing Bactrocera zonata (Tephritidae: Diptera). Insects. 2024 Dec 2;15(12):959.
Akbar R, Khan IA, Alajmi RA, Ali A, Faheem B, Usman A, Ahmed AM, El-Shazly M, Farid A, Giesy JP, Aboul-Soud MA. Evaluation of insecticidal potentials of five plant extracts against the stored grain pest, Callosobruchus maculatus (Coleoptera: Bruchidae). Insects. 2022 Nov 13;13(11):1047.
Al-Batty S, Haque SM, Rahman N, Hejaz Azmi SN. Optimized box–Behnken design combined response surface methodology to determine calcium and iron contents using visible, atomic emission and atomic absorption spectrophotometry in vegetables and wastewater samples. Journal of AOAC International. 2023 Jan 1;106(1):99-111.
Aswin Jeno JG, Maria Packiam S, Nakkeeran E. Contact in-vivo larvicidal toxicity and histological studies of Indian herb essential oils loaded niosomes against Aedes aegypti and Culex quinquefasciatus (Diptera: Culicidae). International Journal of Tropical Insect Science. 2022 Apr;42(2):1373-87.
Chen HY, Chen C. A Study of the Response Surface Methodology Model with Regression Analysis in Three Fields of Engineering. Applied System Innovation. 2025 Jul 21;8(4):99.
Das C. Challenges of Emerging Pollutants for the Ecological Receptors in the Twenty-First Century. InPlant-Microbe Interaction under Xenobiotic Exposure 2025 Jul 27 (pp. 81-109). Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore.
Dmello DA, Guru BR, Acharya S. A comprehensive review of ultrasonic patent strategies for mosquito repellence: a landscape analysis. International Journal of Sustainable Engineering. 2025 Dec 31;18(1):2543114.
Farid A, Akbar R, Khan SW, Faheem B, Rafiq N, Khan G Z. Assessment of resistance and susceptibility in Culex quinquefasciatus larvae exposed to conventional and novel insecticides. Zoo Botanica. 2025 Aug 31; 3(2): 29-42.
Fang J, Wang J, Han Y, Qi D, Chen T. Bio-based waterproof and oil-repellent coatings for paper packaging: Synergistic effect of oleyl alcohol and chitosan on performance enhancement. Progress in Organic Coatings. 2025 Nov 1;208:109526.
Gupta I, Singh R, Muthusamy S, Sharma M, Grewal K, Singh HP, Batish DR. Plant essential oils as biopesticides: Applications, mechanisms, innovations, and constraints. Plants. 2023 Aug 10;12(16):2916.
Gomez KA, Gomez AA. Statistical procedures for agricultural research. John wiley & sons; 1984 Feb 17.
Hazarika H, Krishnatreyya H. Technological Advancements in Mosquito Repellents: Challenges and Opportunities in Plant-Based Repellents. Acta Parasitologica. 2025 Jun;70(3):117.
Keerthanadevi NS, Senthilkumar KL, Vasanthan A, Kowsalya S, Yuvasri S, Santhosh Kumar M. Development and Evaluation of a Neem Oil-based Mosquito Repellent Cream. Journal of Pharma Insights and Research. 2025 Aug 5;3(4):198-205.
Khan IA, Din MM, Hussain S, Akbar R, Saeed M, Farid A, Fayaz W, Shah RA. A Study of Mosquito Fauna of District Upper Dir, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa-Pakistan. Journal of Entomology and Zoology Studies. 2015;3(5):455-8.
Khizar RZ, Baig F, Naeem-Ullah U, Iqbal N, Hussain A. Chemical characterization and bioactivity of cigarette butt extract as oviposition deterrent and larvicide against Aedes aegypti. Parasitology Research. 2025 Jul;124(7):1-1.
Lamidi S, Olaleye N, Bankole Y, Obalola A, Aribike E, Adigun I. Applications of response surface methodology (RSM) in product design, development, and process optimization. IntechOpen; 2022 Sep 16.
Lazzari, C.R., 2024. Why do repellents repel?. Current Opinion in Insect Science, 66, p.101277.
Manimaran A, Cruz MM, Muthu C, Vincent S, Ignacimuthu S. Larvicidal and knockdown effects of some essential oils against Culex quinquefasciatus Say, Aedes aegypti (L.) and Anopheles stephensi (Liston). Advances in Bioscience and Biotechnology. 2012 Nov 26;3(07):855-62.
Manzoor S, Akbar R, Hussain A, Ali A, Faheem B, Zaman M, Farid A, Hussain I, Khan IA, Perveen K, Bukhari NA. Toxicity effect of Ricinus communis methanolic extracts against Bactrocera cucurbitae (Diptera: Tephritidae). Plant Protection Science. 2025 Jan 1;61(1).
Marinrojes AJ, Uthumange SS. Nature's Defense—An Overview of Plant-Based Mosquito Repellents. Transformative Applied Research in Computing, Engineering, Science and Technology. 2025 Apr 29:126-32.
Marshall T, Dosoky NS, Satyal P, Setzer WN. Aroma Compounds of Carrier Oils. AppliedChem. 2023 Dec 8;3(4):546-80.
Näslund J, Ahlm C, Islam K, Evander M, Bucht G, Lwande OW. Emerging mosquito-borne viruses linked to Aedes aegypti and Aedes albopictus: global status and preventive strategies. Vector-Borne and Zoonotic Diseases. 2021 Oct 1;21(10):731-46.
Nerio LS, Olivero-Verbel J, Stashenko E. Repellent activity of essential oils: a review. Bioresource technology. 2010 Jan 1;101(1):372-8.
Özokan G, Bilginer A, Mızrak Z, Işıkoğlu S, Beler M, Ünal İ, Cansız D, Alturfan AA, Emekli-Alturfan E. Comparison of the cytotoxicity and zebrafish embryo toxicity of insect repellent ingredients: p-Menthane-3, 8-diol synthesized by green chemistry from Eucalyptus citriodora and N, N-diethyl-meta-toluamide. Drug and Chemical Toxicology. 2024 Nov 1;47(6):1193-204.
Peach DA, Almond M, Gries R, Gries G. Lemongrass and cinnamon bark: plant essential oil blend as a spatial repellent for mosquitoes in a field setting. Journal of Medical Entomology. 2019 Sep 3;56(5):1346-52.
Pohlit AM, Lopes NP, Gama RA, Tadei WP, de Andrade Neto VF. Patent literature on mosquito repellent inventions which contain plant essential oils–a review. Planta medica. 2011 Apr;77(06):598-617..
Qi Y, Chen Y, Liu G, Shen L. Study on microwave extraction of berberine coloring compound and extracts stability: Process optimization by Response Surface Method (RSM). Dyes and Pigments. 2025 Jun 1;237:112609.
Quinn GP, Keough MJ. Experimental design and data analysis for biologists. Cambridge university press; 2002 Mar 21.
Salehi M, Farkhani EM, Moghri J, Ghasemian A, Tabatabaee SS, Hooshmand E. Global dengue fever management in health systems: identifying strategies, challenges and solutions–a scoping review protocol. BMJ open. 2025 Apr 1;15(4):e097085.
Sasmita HI, Neoh KB, Ernawan B, Indarwatmi M, Nasution IA, Fitrianto N, Ramadhani T, Isnani T, Sasaerila YH, Rahman RL, Yusmalinar S. Integrated vector management with the sterile insect technique component for the suppression of Aedes aegypti in an urban setting in Indonesia. PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases. 2025 Jul 7;19(7):e0013290.
Silapanuntakul S, Keanjoom R, Pandii W, Boonchuen S, Sombatsiri K. Efficacy of Thai neem oil against Aedes aegypti (L.) larvae. Southeast Asian J. Trop. Med. Public Health. 2016 May 1;47(3):410-5.
Sridhar D, Parimalarenganayaki S. Evaluation of sources, spatial and temporal distribution, ecological and health risk associated with CAF (Caffeine) and DEET (N, N-diethyl-meta-toluamide) contamination in the urban groundwater parts of Vellore city, Tamilnadu, India. Environmental Geochemistry and Health. 2025 Feb;47(2):44.
Sudhakaran G, VN D, Bharti SA, Kumar A, Kannan J, Arockiaraj J. Invisible enemies: evaluating human health threats of mosquito repellents through animal studies. Drug and Chemical Toxicology. 2024 Nov 1;47(6):1341-57.
Szpisják-Gulyás N, Al-Tayawi AN, Horváth ZH, László Z, Kertész S, Hodúr C. Methods for experimental design, central composite design and the Box–Behnken design, to optimise operational parameters: A review. Acta Alimentaria. 2023 Dec 4;52(4):521-37.
Tang Y, Li H, Song Q. Lemongrass essential oil and its major component citronellol: evaluation of larvicidal activity and acetylcholinesterase inhibition against Anopheles sinensis. Parasitology Research. 2024 Sep;123(9):315.
Wei P, Zhao F, Wang Z, Wang Q, Chai X, Hou G, Meng Q. Sesame (Sesamum indicum L.): A comprehensive review of nutritional value, phytochemical composition, health benefits, development of food, and industrial applications. Nutrients. 2022 Sep 30;14(19):4079.
Wu YS, Osman AI, Hosny M, Elgarahy AM, Eltaweil AS, Rooney DW, Chen Z, Rahim NS, Sekar M, Gopinath SC, Mat Rani NN. The toxicity of mercury and its chemical compounds: molecular mechanisms and environmental and human health implications: a comprehensive review. Acs Omega. 2024 Jan 22;9(5):5100-26.
Yadav DK, Rathee S, Sharma V, Patil UK. A comprehensive review on insect repellent agents: medicinal plants and synthetic compounds. Anti-Inflammatory & Anti-Allergy Agents in Medicinal Chemistry. 2024 Oct 16.
Zhang J, Zhang M, Bhandari B, Wang M. Basic sensory properties of essential oils from aromatic plants and their applications: a critical review. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition. 2024 Aug 6;64(20):6990-7003.
Zheng W, Zhang Y, Huang J, Wu Q, Fu J, Wen Y, Fang S, Yang X, Xia Q. Repellent Activity of DEET and Biont-Based Mosquito Repellents in the Chinese Market Against the Asian Long-Horned Tick, Haemaphysalis longicornis. Insects. 2025 Apr 29;16(5):467.
Zhu H, Tao R, Yu Q, Yu M, Zhou Y, Fu Q. The mediating roles of obesity indicators and serum albumin in the association of DEET exposure with depression and sleep disorders in adults: evidence from NHANES 2007-2016. BMC Public Health. 2025 May 6;25(1):1658.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Abid Farid, Hajra Bibi, Rasheed Akbar, Azhar Rashid, Gul Zamin Khan
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
